FSJ & Touchstone Fundraising

From the March/April, 2010 issue of Touchstone


England Sings by Lucy E. Carroll

England Sings

Singing and the Imagination of Devotion:
Vocal Aesthetics in Early English Protestant Culture

by Susan Tara Brown
Paternoster, 2008
(350 pages, $29.90, hardcover)

reviewed by Lucy E. Carroll

As the great liturgies of the Western and Eastern churches developed, much of their music came to be reserved for singing by a schola cantorum or choir, although some segments of the Ordinary, the unchanging prayers of the Mass, could be sung by the faithful. The great body of early hymnody, though, grew up not for singing in the Eucharistic liturgies, but for the Divine Office, and for devotions such as Benediction, novenas, and the like.

With the advent of Protestantism, greater emphasis was placed on the participation of the faithful in religious services through the singing of hymns and psalms. The personal nature of many hymns fit the Protestant approach of individual response to God’s word. In time, the singing of the congregation became more important than that of scholas and choirs. Tracing this transition in England is the goal of Susan Tara Brown’s Singing and the Imagination of Devotion.

Brown’s examination of attitudes toward singing and hymnody in the late sixteenth through the eighteenth centuries is exhaustive in its scope. While a basic knowledge of music history is needed to understand all of her references, she illustrates her topic with intriguing and illuminating quotations from period writers both well-known and obscure. The many books, letters, and documents she has uncovered show that, far from being dour and dispassionate in their approach to singing, English Protestants looked on singing as both an important and a pleasurable method of prayer.

Historical Background

When Henry VIII, after breaking with Rome, ordered the suppression of the monasteries, the English church lost a valuable resource: the monastery choir schools. Henry closed some 2,000 of these schools, leaving only a few in royal chapels and universities. Choir schools did grow up in the cathedrals, and the new, shorter service, in English, gave rise to a new tradition of choral anthems.

However, in smaller towns and villages, singing was often led by the parish clerk, with poor results. To correct this deficiency, such figures as Isaac Watts, Thomas Morley, Thomas Mace, and Cotton Mather began to write books and articles stressing the importance of good form in singing. Rather than stressing the mechanics of the voice, their works taught theory and improvisatory singing, and stressed good posture and clear articulation of the text.

From the Restoration in 1660 until about 1770, secular and theatrical music prospered in England, and visiting Italian singers, with their bel canto style, were much admired. These singers, most of whom were Roman Catholic, were not permitted to sing in the royal chapels or cathedrals, but they were hired for entertainment even for royal events. Gradually, elements of the Italian style of singing were merged with the less ornate English style.

Emphasis on the Word

Singing was of great importance in the Protestant churches, for there the emphasis was on the Word itself, and singing was a fit vehicle to carry that Word. Thus, writers of church music looked first to Scripture, particularly to the psalms. Psalters proliferated; the Sternhold and Hopkins Psalter went through 600 editions in some 270 years, and was even brought to America. Originally supplying only melodies, the psalm settings eventually began to include harmony. The faithful were urged to sing psalms at home as well as in church, thus making the home a little chapel and a source of edification to others.

After psalms, individual hymns proliferated. The subjects of these were often extremely personal and homely; many seventeenth-century hymns were written for ordinary day-to-day activities, such as “When we put on our apparel,” “A hymn whilst we are washing,” and “When we are walking in a garden,” or for specific situations, such as the “Lamentation in times of excessive rain.”

Since fidelity to the Word was paramount, most sacred music was vocal music, and the Puritans and Nonconformists questioned any use of instrumental music at all. Many Anglican leaders, however, pointed to the use of instruments in the Old Testament as validation for their use, as well as for the inclusion of more ornate passages in vocal music.

Acting a Grace

English Protestants even equated singing with meditation, believing that the inner life was nurtured through the emotions and feelings generated in song. This was quite different from the meditative methods of Catholic mystics, who sought union with God through silent meditation.

Puritan and Anglican divines called singing “acting a grace”: Since it combined the intellect with the affections, imagination, and whole body, it implied a wholeness, a happy union of the rational and emotive sides of the soul. Brown concludes that the early English Protestants could reconcile holiness and pleasure, spirit and body, reason and imagination, through their music. This wholeness, she writes, was a more complex approach to singing as prayer than is understood today. Their singing was a source of both pleasure and transcendence to the English Protestants, and gave them a foretaste of the fullness of song to be enjoyed in heaven.

Touchstone is made possible by donor support. 
Become a Friend of Touchstone today
by making a tax-deductible donation to support
its ongoing publication both online and in print!

“England Sings” first appeared in the March/April 2010 issue of Touchstone. If you enjoyed this article, you'll find more of the same in every issue. Support the work of Touchstone by subscribing today!

comments powered by Disqus

This page and all site content © 2017 by The Fellowship of St. James. All rights reserved. Please send comments, suggestions, and bad link reports to webmaster@touchstonemag.com.


The Still Small God

The Mustard Seed & the Wonders of His Kingdom


Doctors Delusional

Transgender Disorder & Really Bad Psychiatry


Weather or Not

On Christian Stewardship & Climate Change


Greater Than the Sum

Why the Design in Living Things Goes Far Beyond Machinery


Believe Free or Die

On Mathematical Certainty & the Liberty of Faith


ETI In the Sky

What the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligent Life Means for Us

Publisher of:

All content © The Fellowship of St. James — 2017. All rights reserved. — webmaster@touchstonemag.com.
Returns, refunds, and privacy policy.