Law and Gospel, Constitution and Church by S. M. Hutchens

Law & Gospel, Constitution & Church

by S. M. Hutchens

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. (Thomas Jefferson, Declaration of Independence of the United States of America)

If you obey the voice of the Lord your God, being careful to do all his commandments which I command you this day, the Lord your God will set you high above all the nations of the earth . . . and the Lord will make you abound in prosperity. . . . But if you will not obey the voice of the Lord your God or be careful to do that which I command you this day, then all these curses will come upon you and overtake you. . . . The Lord will send upon you curses, confusion, and frustration in all that you undertake to do, until you are destroyed and perish quickly on account of the evil of your doings. (Deuteronomy 28)

If you keep my commandments, you will remain in my love, just as I have kept my Father's commandments and remain in his love. (John 15:10)

It appears the passages above describe two Gods, one of whom makes life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness unalienable human rights, the other a considerably less generous one who makes a nation's enjoyment of these goods dependent on obedience to his commands, with terrible curses to be visited upon those who disobey them—the "Old Testament God" disavowed by Marcion and his numerous kin, ancient and modern: "If . . . then . . ." this God says in revelation of his character and disposition to make human happiness conditional on obedience, with no reference to human equality, rights, or inalienability. It is interesting how so many who profess belief in the biblical God should have seized upon the First Document of the American founding as self-evident truth, when in fact their Scriptures know nothing of this, and are comfortable with revising his character on the authority of the Bible-cropping Thomas Jefferson and his kindred spirits.

Unwritten Constitutions

The Supreme Court of the United States has followed a disconcerting pattern for at least the last several generations in that justices appointed by conservative presidents and expected to decide cases accordingly have defected and formed majorities with the Court's liberals against the expectations and desires of those who approved their appointments. Noting the phenomenon, Adrian Vermeule, Tyler Professor of Constitutional Law at Harvard Law School, observes in his Washington Post online column of July 8, 2020, that there are three predominating explanations for this: first, that the defecting justices are simply following their best interpretation of the Constitution; second, that they have been overwhelmed by and absorbed the mind-habits of the left-liberal elite. Vermeule finds these alternatives unsatisfying and suggests a third with more explanatory power:

The justices are indeed acting faithfully to law, but not by enforcing the written Constitution and laws. Rather what they enforce is our real, unwritten constitution, a set of understandings that underlies and shapes our interpretation of the law. Justices interpret open-ended provisions  ("due process of law") in light of this unwritten constitution. And because the background small-c constitution embodies a liberal order, it is unsurprising that their decisions do as well. . . . This unwritten constitution is best understood as a sociopolitical order that privileges a particular set of commitments held passionately by educated urban professionals, what Joel Kotkin and Fred Siegel have termed "gentry liberals." Among these, and relevant to the current term, are ensuring a high rate of immigration, encouraged by policies against full enforcement of the law, and protecting sexual expression and liberty, including contraception, abortion and unconstrained expression of sexual preference and gender identity. These beliefs are not spelled out explicitly in law, yet they exert a gravitational force that powerfully influences the justices' interpretations. These unwritten norms allow the expression of dissenting views, but only as dissenting views. They thus exert the most force on justices who are otherwise least convinced of the conservative position in a given case. Hence the most conservative justices rarely defect. But in critical cases, involving central commitments of the unwritten constitution, it is highly likely that one or more of the middling conservative justices will do so.

I find this explanation compelling, not least because it replicates in the political sphere a phenomenon seen in the life of the churches, in which the equivalent of "gentry liberalism" is expressed by a progressive church intelligentsia, which also, in undergoing the process of modernization—largely, I believe, by status-seeking from the Zeitgeist (Schleiermacher's project) and justification of forbidden "lifestyles"—itself gives rise to an unwritten church constitution alleged to originate in the example and teaching of a liberal Jesus. In both cases there is a release from a "conservative" demand for order and penalty-exacting discipline of Law (considered in its broadest sense), which tends toward the separation of the institutional fibers and dissolution of both church and state.

The Gospel as the Enemy of the Law

The chief instrument of the termination of Christianity in the face of post-Enlightenment modernizing influence has been having yet another go at the old device of placing gospel and Law in opposition, which its Founder denied doing when accused of it, that is, when he was reproached for actually opposing the law by those he had accused of misunderstanding it—when he was indicted by his conservative opponents of that day's equivalent of modernism. The old Christian maxim that the New Testament is latent in the Old and the Old is patent in the New suffers in the hands of church liberals promoting a new and more kindly rule that in effect makes Jesus guilty as charged as an abrogator of the Torah in favor of a rule of charity that supplants it, a release from its rigors without subjugation to the even greater ones of a gospel in which the law is latent and constituent in Christ.


S. M. Hutchens is a senior editor and longtime writer for Touchstone.

A Journal of Mere Christianity—Delivered to Your Door

  • Essays on theology, culture, and the Church
  • Contributors from across the Christian traditions
Subscribe (Print + Online)

Six print issues (one year) of Touchstone, plus full online access and PDF downloads for only $39.95.

Subscribe (Online Only)

Get a one-year full-access subscription to the Touchstone online archives for only $19.95.


bulk subscriptions

Order Touchstone subscriptions in bulk and save $10 per sub! Each subscription includes 6 issues of Touchstone plus full online access to touchstonemag.com—including archives, videos, and pdf downloads of recent issues for only $29.95 each! Great for churches or study groups.

Transactions will be processed on a secure server.


more on America from the online archives

29.4—July/August 2016

Deep Roots

Russell Kirk: American Conservative by Bradley J. Birzer by Hunter Baker

30.5—Sept/Oct 2017

Passions' Republic

The Christian Cure for What Ails Modern Politics by David Bradshaw

29.2—March/April 2016

Family Phases

The History of Family Strength in America May Reveal Good News by Allan C. Carlson


more from the online archives

30.4—July/Aug 2017

Soul Comforter

on Emily Dickinson & the Source of Our Hope by Josh Mayo

26.5—Sept/Oct 2013

More than Schooling

The Perils of Pragmatism in Christian Attitudes Toward the Liberal Arts by Robin Phillips

16.10—December 2003

Calculating Christmas

on the Story Behind December 25 by William J. Tighe

calling all readers

Please Donate

"There are magazines worth reading but few worth saving . . . Touchstone is just such a magazine."
—Alice von Hildebrand

"Here we do not concede one square millimeter of territory to falsehood, folly, contemporary sentimentality, or fashion. We speak the truth, and let God be our judge. . . . Touchstone is the one committedly Christian conservative journal."
—Anthony Esolen, Touchstone senior editor

Support Touchstone

00